Best Women's Down Vests of 2024
The top Down and Synthetic Insulated Vests for warmth, weather resistance, comfort, fit, and style
August 22nd, 2024, updated to include new models, plus-size winners, and PFAS
Home > Gear Reviews > Apparel
Vests are the ideal layering piece for when the seasons start to shift. You can layer an insulated vest in a variety of ways in any season to offer just the right amount of warmth that often can’t be achieved with a jacket. Vests are versatile and many have technical features found in other jackets while maintaining a casual style that can easily be taken from the trail to town.
We dove into the nitty gritty of the best down and synthetic insulated vests on the market, first researching and then testing for ourselves in the mountains of Colorado, from deep in the backcountry to breweries in town. After analyzing warmth, weather resistance, comfort, fit, features, and style, we found the best vests out there for any activity.
Looking for men's vests? See our guide to Best Men's Down Vests
We create reader-supported, objective gear reviews independently selected by our editors. This story may contain affiliate links, which help fund our website. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission, without costing you an extra cent. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body! Learn more.
Comparison Table
| Women's Down Vests | TREELINE AWARD | Sizes | Insulation | Hood | Packable? | Best for | Weight | Responsible Down Certified? | Shell | Pockets |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patagonia Down Sweater Vest | Best overall Read why |
XXS-XXL | 900-fill Responsible Down 100% virgin goose down | Hooded options available? | Yes | Multisport | 7.1 oz | Yes | NetPlus postconsumer recycled ripstop nylon | 2 handwarmer, 1 internal zip chest ocket |
| REI Co-op 650 Down Vest | Best affordable Read why |
XS-3X | 650-fill down | No | Yes | Town, hiking | 7 oz | no? | recycled nylon ripstop with DWR | |
| Rab Microlight | Best for bad weather Read why |
XS-XXL | Recycled 700FP Down with Nikwax Hydrophobic Finish | no | yes | multisport | 9.2 oz | yes | Pertex Quantum Ripstop | 2 handwarmer |
| Outdoor Research Cold Front | Best for winter Read why |
XS-XXL | 700-fill-power Responsibly Sourced Down | yes | yes | casual | 15.1 oz | yes | 30-denier Pertex Quantum Eco double-ripstop polyester | 2 handwarmer |
| Mountain Hardwear Down Stretch | Best for aerobic activities Read why |
XS-XL | 700-fill RDS-certified down | No | Yes | Aerobic activities | 8.1 oz | yes | 20D Durable Stretch Doubleweave, 86% Nylon, 14% Elastane | |
| Cotopaxi Fuego | Best plus-size Read why |
XXS-4X | 800-fill-power goose down | no | yes | casual | 10 oz | no? | Ripstop nylon | 4 (2 handwarmer, 2 internal) |
| Montbell Thermawrap | Best synthetic Read why |
S-XL | EXCELOFT synthetic insulation | No | Yes | Fast and light, wet conditions | 6.8 oz | N/A | 12 D nylon ripstop with DWR | 5 (2 zippered handwarmer, 1 zip chest, 2 internal zip) |
The Winners
Best Overall Vest: Patagonia Down Sweater Vest
Weight: 7.1 oz.
Available sizes: XXS-XXL
Fit: regular
Shell fabric: 100% recycled 20D nylon ripstop with PFC-free DWR
Insulation type: 800-fill RDS-certified down
Pockets: 2 handwarmer, 1 internal zip chest
pocket
What we liked: comfortable, great warmth-to-weight ratio
What could be better: expensive
After extensive research and testing, looking at all the media and customer reviews on vests we could find, one vest stood out as an obvious favorite among outdoor media professionals and everyday users alike: the Patagonia Down Sweater vest.
This vest is comfortable, light, versatile, durable, and sustainably made with noticeably high-quality construction. If you’re looking for a great everyday vest for fall walks and casual hangs that’s still technical enough to take on the trail, this vest will serve you well. That's why we give the Patagonia Down Sweater our top award of best down vest.
Patagonia Down Sweater Vest
The Down Sweater Vest is made with a 100% recycled 20-denier nylon ripstop outer shell fabric that’s treated with a PFC-free Durable Water Resistant (DWR) coating for water repellency. The vest is stuffed with 800-fill responsibly-sourced down that’s certified by Responsible Down Standard, and the vest is Fair Trade Certified-sewn.
You can read more about perfluorinated chemicals (PFCs/PFAs) in waterproofing and why the outdoor industry is moving away from them here.
This vest has two perfectly-placed hand pockets on the exterior, plus one internal chest pocket that doubles as a stuff sack for the vest, which packs down a little smaller than a Nalgene water bottle.
The baffles on this vest are part of what makes it stand out from others in our test. More baffles in a down garment typically means extra warmth, since the down feathers are more concentrated. When testing in the Colorado high country while hiking, foraging, and camping, we found the Down Sweater to be super cozy, especially considering it’s fairly light.
In fact, this is the softest and coziest vest in our test and the one we reached for most often when we wanted to take off the chill. While the Outdoor Research Cold Front was the warmest in our test, it isn’t as versatile outside of wintry conditions, which makes the Down Sweater ideal for everyday use across three seasons. This vest is among the warmer vests in our test—the Rab Microlight was slightly warmer than this vest, but not by much.
Some of the other features we love about this vest are the pockets. The zippered hand pockets are very spacious. They are placed in a normal location near the waist, so they can’t be fully accessed when wearing a pack with a hip belt, but they can be at least partially unzipped. The inside drop pockets are also large and can fit even the largest of cell phones, while the internal chest pocket can fit most phones.
When it comes to mobility, this vest is very comfortable, though it does not have the stretch of the Mountain Hardwear. The shoulder openings are spacious and comfortable without looking like shoulder pads. Overall, we think this vest runs true to size. Patagonia has been getting better in recent years with offering a wider range of sizes. We appreciate that this one goes up to XXL but would love to see it available in a 3X, too.
Another bonus is Patagonia’s warranty under their Ironclad Guarantee—they will repair or replace any garments that are not up to their standard. Or, if you’ve just put some good wear-and-tear into your garment, they have helpful guides for cleaning and repairing, or you can send it to Patagonia for professional repairs for a small charge (if it’s not a warranty item).
Patagonia Worn Wear is also a great resource, whether you’re looking to trade in your old gear or find a used Down Sweater Vest for a fraction of the retail price—plus, it’s easier on the earth. Additionally, this vest comes with a small patch kit in case you do get any holes in the fabric.
There isn’t much we don’t like about this vest for everyday use. It does lean on the expensive side, but with that comes a more sustainably-made vest with very high-quality materials and construction, in addition to a great warranty and repairs policy.
For leaning on the more casual side, this vest is still quite light and packable, which makes it great for travel.
It is not quite as technical as other vests in our test, like the Rab Microlight or Mountain Hardwear Stretchdown. And it’s not as light as the Montbell synthetic vest. If you’re looking for a vest that’s primarily for use in the backcountry, whether you’re looking for weight savings or more technical features, consider one of these instead.
The Down Sweater vest popped up numerous times in our research, with positive media and customer reviews across the board. It comes recommended by Switchback Travel and Wirecutter (written by Treeline Review founder, Liz Thomas), among others. Aside from a few remarks on sizing (we’d recommend sizing up if you’re on the fence), most customers on Patagonia’s website left 5-star reviews for the Down Sweater vest. The bottom line: If you want one great vest to do it all with quality construction and understated, casual style, the Down Sweater can’t be beat.
The Down Sweater vest is the vest version of our overall winner for Best Down Jacket in our Best Down Jackets guide. We also dedicate a single product in-depth review to the Patagonia Down Sweater Jacket.
Best Affordable Down Vest: REI Co-Op 650 Vest
Weight: 7 oz.
Available sizes: XS-3X
Fit: standard
Shell fabric: recycled nylon ripstop with DWR
Insulation type: 650-fill down
Pockets:
What we liked: Comfortable, affordable, good sizing range, uses sustainable materials
What could be better: Not as warm or weather-protective as others
If you’re looking for a good down vest that won’t lighten your wallet too much, we think the REI Co-op 650 vest offers an excellent value. It’s a warm, comfortable, and reasonably durable vest that is a fraction of the price of others in our test. You’ll get all the features we expect in a down vest without breaking your budget or having your gear fall apart after minimal use.
REI co-op 650 vest
The REI Co-op 650 vest, as expected with the name, is made with 650-fill down, which is on the low end of any others in our test, meaning the down used in this vest is not as lofty as others. The outer shell is constructed with a bluesign-approved recycled nylon ripstop that’s treated with a DWR coating. With dual zippered hand pockets and a spacious internal drop pocket on one side of the vest, there’s ample space to carry essentials.
While this vest is not the warmest in our test, it’s still quite cozy and is on the lighter side and small enough to pack into the backcountry as long as going ultralight is not a concern.
While the REI Co-op 650 vest offers excellent value, there are a few things it lacks compared to others in our test. The fill power is lower than all other down vests in our test, and notably lower than the 800-fill of the Down Sweater. It’s also not quite as warm or weather resistant as others, but overall the performance for the price is very good.
With any budget item there are features you’ll have to sacrifice and we still think this is a great piece of gear. However, if you’re looking for a warmer vest with a higher loft and better down insulation, consider others in our review.
The jacket version of the 650 vest, the REI Co-Op 650 Down jacket, is the best budget winner in our Best Down Jackets guide. The similar Norseland Parka 2.0 is also a favorite and we dedicate an in-depth review on why we like this REI Norseland Parka.
Best Vest for Bad Weather: Rab Down Microlight Vest
Weight: 9.2 oz.
Available sizes: XS-XL
Fit: standard
Shell fabric: 30D Pertex Quantum nylon ripstop
Insulation type: 700-fill GRS-certified down with hydrophobic Nikwax treatment
Pockets: 2 handwarmer
What we liked: weather-resistant shell and hydrophobic down stand up well to damp conditions
What could be better: not as light as other down vests
The Rab Microlight vest is an excellent all-around down vest that stood out in our test for its notable weather protection. Unlike any other down insulated vest in our test, the down inside the Microlight’s baffles is treated with a PFC-free Nixwax hydrophobic coating. The Durable Water Resistance (DWR) treatment is PFAS-free. You can read more about perfluorinated chemicals (PFCs/PFAs) in waterproofing and why the outdoor industry is moving away from them here. This paired with the Pertex Quantum shell and DWR make this down vest perform particularly well in damp conditions. If you’re often out in bad weather—like damp PNW days or misty and dewy mornings on the trail—and are looking for a down vest that will hold up in the clouds, make this your top choice.
Rab Down Microlight Vest
The Microlight vest is constructed with a 30-denier Pertex Quantum shell material that’s treated with a DWR finish for added water repellency. The denier rating is the highest of any of the vests in our test, which helps to make this shell material both more durable and more weather resistant. Inside the baffles you’ll find 700-fill GRS-certified responsibly-sourced down that’s been treated with a hydrophobic coating. (This certification is different from RDS down; rather than being ethically sourced from the animals, it’s made with certified recycled down, which is another sustainable option.) These features don’t make the vest fully waterproof, but it stood up well to light rain and heavy wind on hikes and foraging adventures in Colorado’s high country.
The Microlight has two zippered hand pockets and stretchy seams around the shoulders that help make the vest more comfortable and offer some added range of motion.
Overall, this is an excellent all-around vest without many downsides. It is, however, on the heavier side. It’s still light enough for most outdoor adventures, but if weight savings is a priority you’ll want to consider other options, though you will sacrifice some of the weather-resistant qualities that this vest offers.
The Microlight is ultimately a good value vest for all-around use that stands out especially in bad weather. With a quality shell material and hydrophobic down, it still is less expensive than two of our other winners (the Patagonia and Mountain Hardwear vests are both more expensive than the Rab).
The Rab Microlight Vest is the overall winner in our Best Men's Down Vests guide where we especially liked the balance of function and sustainability.
Best Insulated Vest for Winter: Outdoor Research Cold Front Hooded Down Vest II
Weight: 16.9 oz.
Available sizes: XS-XXL
Fit: standard
Shell fabric: Pertex Quantum Eco shell
Insulation type: 700-fill 90% RDS-certified down
Pockets: 2 handwarmer
What we liked: ultra-plush warmth, good weather protection
What could be better: too heavy and bulky for backcountry use
When the snow starts to fly and the temperature drops, you need more than a lightweight layer to keep you warm. That’s where the ultra-cozy Outdoor Research Cold Front vest comes in. After testing on chilly shoulder-season camping trips in the Rockies, this vest proved to be the warmest and most weather protective in our test. Plus, unlike any others in our test, the Cold Front features an insulated hood and plush fleece lining in the collar that kept us extra toasty. If warmth and coziness is your top priority, this is the vest for you.
Outdoor Research Cold Front Hooded Down Vest II
The Cold Front vest is made with a bluesign®-approved Pertex Quantum Eco shell that in our tests stands up better than most others to light precipitation. (The Rab Microlight performed slightly better in water repellency, but both of these have notably better weather protection than others in our test.) This vest is stuffed in the body and hood with 700-fill down that’s Responsible Down Standard (RDS)-certified.
For pockets, the Cold Front features two zippered hand pockets and one interior mesh drop pocket that can fit a large phone.
One of the coziest features of this vest, aside from the toasty-warm hood, is the high-loft, ultra-soft fleece lining that insulates the inside of the collar. It’s soft and warm and adds a touch of fun style to the vest. The vest fits true-to-size, but if you like plenty of room for lofting and layers, consider sizing up. (Also worth noting, we tested the jacket version of the Cold Front for our Best plus-size winter gear story, but sadly the vest is not yet offered in plus sizing.)
There aren’t many downsides to this vest, given that it’s used in appropriately cold conditions. It’s not as versatile as others and certainly meant for cold weather, so you won’t need this layer for those still-mostly-warm fall days. But it does offer superior warmth. We think having a vest like this for winter is great when you want warmth in your core area but still like the arm mobility a vest offers, or just want the style and flair of a vest. (If it’s truly frigid, you’re going to want a full coat.)
The only other trade-off with the Cold Front is that it is heavy compared to other vests we tested. This layer is meant for days lounging at the base of the ski hill, casual winter hikes, and around-town adventures in cold and snowy weather. If you’re looking for a warm layer to drag with you into the backcountry, you’ll find lighter and more packable options out there.
The original model of this vest has a heap of 5-star customer reviews, with many commenting on the warmth, style, and quality construction. The Cold Front II has a slightly different baffle construction and adds the lofty fleece collar, both features that we think are upgrades and only make this vest even cozier. For ultimate warmth and great style, this is the best vest for wintery days.
Best Vest for Aerobic Activities: Mountain Hardwear Stretchdown Light Vest
Weight: 8.1 oz.
Available sizes: XS-XL
Fit: standard
Shell fabric: 20D Durable Stretch Doubleweave, 86% Nylon, 14% Elastane
Insulation type: 700-fill RDS-certified down
Pockets:
What we liked: Stretchy, comfortable, great for freedom of movement
What could be better: price, shell fabric could be more water-resistant and breathable
Even with the lack of sleeves, not all vests offer a wide range of motion due to the stiff shell materials used for down insulation. Mountain Hardwear changes that with their Stretchdown shell material. For active pursuits, whether hiking, backpacking, or rock climbing, the Stretchdown vest offers the most comfort and range of motion of any vest in our test. We used this on long and tough late summer backpacking trips in the high alpine of northern Colorado and only took it off in the heat of the day. If you want a vest that can stand up and stay comfortable for all sorts of outdoor adventures, this is it.
Mountain Hardwear Stretchdown Light Vest
The Stretchdown Light vest is made with a stretchy, 20-denier shell material that’s both durable and comfortable. On boulder field scrambles, we had no issues with abrasion when wearing this vest. The Stretchdown has 700-fill RDS-certified down in the staggered baffles. It’s not as lofty as other vests in our test, but that sleeker design is part of what makes it great for aerobic activities like hiking and climbing. We were less likely to overheat in this vest than any others in our test.
For pockets, it’s got two zippered hand pockets plus two internal stash pockets. On our testing hikes and backpacking trips, we found that the vest blocks wind well in 25-mph gusts above treeline, but the water resistance was not as good as others in our test; it wetted out faster than the others.
The only real downside to this vest is that it’s on the pricey side. If you want the functionality of the stretchy shell material you’ll have to fork over the extra cash, but that’s worth it if you plan to use this vest primarily for active outdoor pursuits. While this vest is stretchy and comfortable for moving in, the fabric could be more water-resistant and breathable. But only a certain level of breathability is to be expected with an insulated garment like this in the first place, so this is a minor complaint.
If you want a vest that’s ideal for a lot of movement and big outdoor adventures, we think this should be your top choice. We also had the most confidence in the durability of this vest; it didn’t snag or tear when bushwhacking and scrambling for an entire day off-trail. No other vest in our test was as comfortable on the trail (or scrambling and bushwhacking off trail), and the freedom of movement that comes with the stretch shell is tough to beat.
Best Plus-Size Vest: Cotopaxi Fuego Down Vest
Weight: 14 oz.
Available sizes: XXS-4X
Shell fabric: 20D nylon ripstop with DWR
Insulation type: 800-fill RDS-certified down
Pockets:
What we liked: great size range, fun colors and style, warm, made with sustainable and ethical business practices
What could be better: heavy, not all colors are offered in plus sizing
We love when high-quality outdoor gear comes in a wide range of sizes, and it’s an extra bonus when that gear looks great, too. The Cotopaxi Fuego has a fun retro style, warm down insulation, and comes in a wide range of sizes, including plus sizes up to 4X. If you’re looking for a great vest that’s offered in plus sizes, we think this is the best option for its performance, style, and overall value.
Cotopaxi Fuego Down Vest
The Fuego has a 20-denier nylon ripstop shell that’s treated with a DWR coating. Inside the baffles is 800-fill responsibly-sourced down insulation that’s wonderfully warm (comparable to the Patagonia and Rab, but not quite as warm as the Outdoor Research). It has two zippered hand pockets, plus two internal stash pockets on one side of the vest—one zippered and one drop-in. The internal zippered pocket can be used as a stuff sack to pack the vest. It also has a drawcord hem that cinches for added warmth. The Fuego fits true to size and is very comfortable whether at camp or out in town.
We tested the Fuego on camping trips in western Colorado in late summer, fall, and as a layer in winter and spring conditions. We also tested in spring and summer at altitude in Idaho and Wyoming.
It’s warm and cozy while having good style for the days you might end up in town instead of camp. All of the four pockets are spacious enough to fit a large phone and plenty of snacks.
It kept us warm on nights at camp near the river when the rain clouds lingered and the temps dipped into the low 40’s. If weight is not much of a concern, this is an excellent vest for all-around use.
The Fuego is about as warm as other similar vests in our test, like the Patagonia Down Sweater, which unfortunately is only available in 2X. The Fuego also comes at a better price, though it’s notably heavier. It kept us warm on nights at camp near the river when the rain clouds lingered and the temps dipped into the low 40’s.
Other features we love with the Fuego include the fact that Cotopaxi offers a great lifetime warranty and offers repairs and gear trade-ins as well. Cotopaxi is conscious of their supply chain, and they’re a Climate Neutral Certified and B-Corp brand. Additionally, their Gear For Good initiative offers grants to communities facing extreme poverty.
The Fuego is one of the heaviest vests in our test, right behind the Outdoor Research Cold Front. This isn’t an issue if you plan to primarily wear this vest around town, on campus, while camping, or on day hikes.
The only other downside is that plus sizing is not offered in every color.
With their size offerings going up to a 4X, and their fit being the most accommodating and true-to-size we’ve found with a major outdoor retailer yet, this Fuego vest is an excellent choice.
Additionally, we've written an in-depth review of the Cotopaxi Fuego jacket and also write about the vest in our News article on Cotopaxi's Extended Sizing options.
Treeline Review writer Gabi Reyes-Acosta says, "“In a market where most gear runs small, where a 3X is not often a true 3X, Cotopaxi made clothing that truly fits.”
You can read more about plus size outdoor apparel that works in our Best Plus Size Outdoor Clothing and Best Plus Size Winter Outdoor Clothing guides.
Best Overall Synthetic Vest: Montbell Thermawrap
Weight: 6.8 oz.
Available sizes: S-XL
Fit: standard
Shell fabric: 12D nylon ripstop with DWR
Insulation type: EXCELOFT synthetic insulation
Pockets: 5 (2 zippered handwarmer, 1 zip chest, 2 internal zip)
What we liked: lightweight and packable, good warmth-to-weight ratio, reversible
What could be better: limited sizing, not as weather protective as others
Down is a great insulating material for its plush coziness, but there are times when synthetic materials are more ideal. If you’re looking for an excellent vest made with synthetic insulation, look no further than the Montbell Thermawrap. This vest is warm, packable, and incredibly lightweight, plus the synthetic materials mean it performs better than down in wet conditions because it stays warm when wet.
Montbell Thermawrap
This vest is ideal for backpackers, any adventures where weight matters, or anyone who prefers the qualities of synthetic insulation over down. We tested this vest hiking around Colorado’s high country mostly in cool and dry late-summer weather. While we did not have the chance to test this in truly wet weather yet, we appreciated the synthetic insulation that stayed warm on drizzly evening forages in the woods. The lightweight construction is also minimal enough for backpacking trips with a lightweight pack.
The Thermawrap is filled with 90 grams of EXCELOFT synthetic insulation that has a good warmth-to-weight ratio. This synthetic insulation also does not lose its loft when wet, like untreated down insulation does. For the shell, the vest has a 12-denier nylon ripstop that’s treated with a water repellent coating. The shell on this is not as weather protective as others in our test, but it still held up on high country hikes. And, because the shell fabric is a lower denier, this vest is not as abrasion resistant as others in our test, so we had to be more careful when hiking in dense foliage, bushwhacking, or scrambling to avoid snags or tears—though we did not sustain any rips or damage to the vest in testing.
An added bonus that’s a standout for this vest: It’s reversible. That means not only do you get two colors and styles in one, you also get double the pockets. Each side of the vest has dual zippered hand pockets and one side of the vest has a zippered chest pocket. The internal pockets are a bit awkward to reach, but still totally usable for items you don’t want to lose but won’t reach for often, like car keys or your wallet.
In testing we found that this vest works well as a stand alone piece in dry weather that’s chilly, but it also layers incredibly well under a rain shell or full puffy jacket for extra protection and warmth. Aside from features and great synthetic insulation, this vest is also the lightest in our test, so if weight is a priority for you, consider this option first.
While this vest is light, warm, and comfortable, it’s not as weather protective as others in our test. When windy or drizzly conditions hit, it noticeably did not stand up to weather as well as others in our test. That’s partly because the denier (the thickness of the individual threads that are woven into the shell) of the shell is smaller than other shell materials. But, since the insulation is synthetic, a little moisture is not as much of a concern as it is with a down-filled vest, since the synthetic stays warm when wet. Our only other gripe with the Thermawrap is the lack of available sizing. We’d love to see a broader range to fit more folks.
Backpacking Light and Wirecutter (originally written by Treeline Review's co-founder Liz Thomas) both recommend the Thermawrap as a top choice for a synthetic vest. The jacket version is a winner in our Best Synthetics Jacket guide.
If you prefer the advantages of synthetic insulation (warm when wet, durable, easier to care for, more affordable) and need a vest that’s just about as light as they come, put this one at the top of your list.
OTHER INSULATED VESTS WE CONSIDERED
PATAGONIA NANO PUFF VEST
Weight: 7.3 oz.
Available sizes: XXS-XXL
Fit: standard
Shell fabric: recycled polyester ripstop with PFC-free DWR
Insulation type: synthetic Primaloft Gold Eco
Pockets: 3 (2 handwarmer, 1 internal)
What we liked: Comfortable, light, flattering fit, made with sustainable business practices
What could be better: not as warm as others
The Nano Puff vest is another popular option that we tested and is an excellent quilted vest for those looking for a synthetic option. The recycled polyester ripstop shell offers good protection from wind and the DWR coating helps fend off light precipitation. It fits true to size and we found this to be one of the more flattering vests in our test.
PATAGONIA NANO PUFF VEST
The Montbell Thermawrap has a better warmth-to-weight ratio than this vest, which is what helped it take the cake as a winner. However, this vest is not much heavier and in our opinion offers better style and excellent functionality. So, if you’re looking for a lightweight synthetic vest but also want something that offers good off-the-trail style, this is a great option.
Weight: 7.1 oz.
Available sizes: XXS-XXL
Fit: trim/fitted
Shell fabric: 20D Tyono shell
Insulation type: Coreloft 60 g recycled polyester fibers (bluesign® approved material)
Pockets:
The Atom line from Arc’teryx has long been a favorite for active insulation, thanks to the breathable materials and strategically placed side panels that offer both freedom of movement and help to vent heat. We have not been able to test this vest yet, but if you’re looking for a vest that performs well during aerobic activities, this is a good one to consider. It’s made with a durable, weather-resistant shell material and synthetic Coreloft insulation that stays warm when wet. Additionally, this vest is on the lighter side, making it a good option for backcountry adventures.
Arc’teryx Atom Vest
Weight: 6 oz.
Available sizes: XXS-XXL
Fit: fitted
Shell fabric: 15D nylon
Insulation type: responsibly-sourced 850-fill down, synthetic Coreloft
Pockets:
This hybrid down vest incorporates synthetic insulation in areas more prone to absorbing moisture, like the shoulders, one of the only vest in our review that has this feature. Additionally, it’s among the lightest options we considered, making it an excellent option for when weight savings matters. While we have not yet had a chance to test this vest, it’s on our list to get out on the trail with soon and we will update this review as soon as we’re able to do so. The Arc’teryx Cerium Jacket was the best hybrid jacket winner in our Best Down Jackets guide and our Best Synthetic Jackets guide.
Arc’teryx Cerium Vest
Weight: 5.6 oz. (for the current men’s version)
Available sizes: men’s sizing S-XXL
Fit: men’s standard fit
Shell fabric: nylon ripstop
Insulation type: 800-fill hydrophobic down
Pockets: 2 zippered handwarmer
What we liked: ultralight, packable, and warm
What could be better: We wish the women’s model had not been discontinued
The Ghost Whisperer line has long been a favorite among the ultralight crowd—few down insulated vests and jackets have been able to match the performance-to-weight ratio of this model. This vest would be a frontrunner for the best lightweight vest, but sadly Mountain Hardwear has decided to discontinue the women’s vest but not the men’s.
Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer
If an ultralight down vest is what you’re looking for, you could consider the men’s version if you’re able to find a good fit. Or, there are still a handful of women’s vests that can be purchased online. If you can find this vest, we recommend it as a good lightweight option. And we hope that in future seasons Mountain Hardwear will bring the women’s model back. The last thing we need is fewer technical options for women’s-specific gear!
You can read about why we like the jacket version in our in-depth review of the Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer/2 or our Best Down Jackets article, where it is our ultralight winner.
Who needs an insulated vest?
Puffy vests are useful pieces of gear to take off the chill without needing a full jacket. They can also be layered over other insulating pieces, like fleece sweaters, and under more protective pieces like rain jackets. A puffer vest is more likely to compress and be packable than a fleece vest, making it better suited for travel and outdoor adventure.
If you’re heading out into bitter cold conditions, a vest probably isn’t the best option and you’ll want to reach for your parka. But for times when it’s chilly or cold, but not quite frigid, a vest can be the perfect companion to keep your core warm. Ultimately, whether a vest is right for you will come down to personal preference.
Buying advice / what to look for in an insulated vest
Type of insulation
Down insulation
Down insulation is made with duck or goose down feathers. Down is known for its superior warmth-to-weight ratio, since the natural feathers offer so much loft, which is what makes the garments warmer by creating dead air space to trap heat. For these reasons, down is an excellent insulation material.
The downsides to down are that it’s more expensive than synthetic insulation. Additionally, when untreated down gets wet, it loses its loft, thus causing it to also lose its warmth. Water-resistant shell materials and hydrophobic coatings on the down feathers themselves are all ways to help down perform better in wet conditions.
Synthetic insulation
Synthetic insulation is typically made with polyester or other similar petroleum-based materials. Synthetic insulation can still be very warm, but it usually does not have the same warmth-to-weight ratio as down, and synthetic garments often do not pack as small as down ones. However, puffer vests made with synthetic insulation are typically more affordable than down vests. Unlike down, when most synthetic insulation materials get wet they still maintain their loft and therefore their warmth. Additionally, if you’re looking for an insulation option that’s vegan, synthetic insulation is a good choice.
Hybrid
A lot of outdoor gear now uses a combination of these two insulation materials, usually in separate and specific compartments of the garment. For example, a puffer vest might have down insulation in most of the body, but synthetic insulation in the shoulders because that’s the area most likely to get wet from precipitation.
Warmth
The level of warmth a puffer vest provides is an important consideration, and warmer doesn’t always necessarily mean better. If you know you’ll be relaxing at camp or hanging in town in cold weather, then the loftiest option is probably the best. But if you want something more versatile for use across seasons, or something that moves and breathes well while being active, you probably don’t want the warmest vest on the market. The fill-power of the down, and even more so the amount of insulation used to stuff the baffles of a puffer vest, will affect how warm it is.
Weather resistance
Insulated down and synthetic puffer vests are generally not designed or intended to be fully wind or waterproof like hardshell waterproof jackets. Instead, their primary purpose is to provide warmth. Still, a good vest will be made with an outer shell material that sheds at least a minor amount of moisture or precipitation. This can be achieved both by the weaving of the shell fabric (higher-denier shells are more durable and weather resistant than ones made with smaller thread diameters).
Another important factor is whether that shell material is treated with a durable water repellent (DWR). This will shed light moisture and precipitation (though it will wet out in a downpour or steady rain or snow).
Fill power
The fill power of down essentially refers to the quality of the feathers. The higher the fill power, the higher the quality, which means better loft and more warmth. Higher fill-power feathers are larger than lower ones, which makes them loftier and allows them to create more dead airspace and warmth. The highest fill power on a vest we considered is the Feathered Friends Eos Down Vest, which has a 900-fill down.
breathability
If you’re looking for a puffer vest to wear while active then how breathable the shell material and vest is overall will be an important factor to consider. Typically, the warmer and more weather resistant a vest is, the less breathable it will be.
Intended Use
When deciding which puffer vest is right for you, think about what you primarily intend to use your vest for. If warmth is your top priority, you may have to spend more and the vest will probably not be as light or breathable as others. And if you’re dealing with particularly cold conditions or if maximum warmth is crucial for you, consider an insulated jacket instead. If you prioritize weight savings for backpacking and other backcountry adventures, you may need to compromise on features. Nail down your preferred features and pick a puffer vest that meets those.
Shell fabric
There are a handful of different types of shell fabrics used on insulated vests, from ripstop treated with water repellent to shells that offer stretch. Consider the denier (the size of the threads the fabric is woven with), water repellency, and other factors when selecting a vest that’s ideal for you.
Sustainability
One of the primary factors we consider when testing gear, including these vests, is how sustainably made that piece of gear is. It’s important to factor durability, since that will help the garment last longer, keeping it out of landfills. We also look for things like responsibly sourced and produced materials. Examples include responsible down or water repellents that avoid the use of PFCs that are harmful to the environment. Many vests use shell material made of recycled material, such as The North Face Ecovest, which uses post consumer reycled polyester in the insulation and recycled nylon for the shell.
We also look for companies that support fair working conditions for the people making their clothing and gear, including vests that are Fair-Trade-Certified sewn.
Additionally, we value companies with good warranty and repair options. Outdoor gear and clothing is expensive to make, especially when done right. So typically, you’ll need to spend a little more to get a vest (or other gear) that’s made with sustainability in mind, but we think that’s worth it, given that you usually get a higher quality garment that’s better for you, the earth, and the people who make it.
Durability
Durability is a crucial factor to consider with any outdoor gear or apparel. We will rarely recommend a piece of gear or apparel that lacks durability (except in the instance of unique pieces of ultralight gear). Durability not only makes gear more sustainable, it also helps you spend less money and acquire less stuff in the long run.
We believe all of the puffer vests in this review offer great durability, and some stand out more than others. Durability and weight can sometimes have an inverse relationship, so if you’re hard on gear, it’s perhaps best not to go for the lightest on the market. And, like sustainably made gear, quality gear that lasts for many seasons will often cost more than gear that is not well made.
Size and fit
Always be sure to check the fit and sizing chart, or try on in a store, to avoid unnecessary returns. If you want to be able to put lots of layers under your vest, consider sizing up. A puffer vest should fit loose enough to allow for layering while maintaining the loft in the vest. When a down vest fits too snug, the down is constricted without enough room to fully loft, which in turn causes it to be less warm. But, if you want a vest to wear over minimal layers for aerobic activities, it’s better to go with your true size. With a women’s vest in particular, make sure that it is cut to not become too tight around the waist, hips, and chest.
Weight
Do you plan to use the puffer vest for mostly casual wear, or are you looking for a vest that you can stuff into your pack for long backcountry trips? For casual wear, weight is not as important, though it’s still a factor worth considering. If you want the vest for backcountry adventures, weight savings should be a primary factor.
Compressibility
In general, down insulation is more compressible than synthetic insulation. So if you want your puffer vest to pack very small, whether for travel or an outdoor adventure, you may want to consider a down vest over a synthetic one. A down or synthetic puffer vest will generally compress down better than a fleece vest or vest made of other material.
Pockets
All of the vests in this review have at least two hand pockets, though some have additional chest and internal pockets. Consider how much you want to be able to carry and how important pockets are to you and factor that in when deciding on a vest that’s right for you. A hand pocket is a handy place to store a phone for easy access and to prevent its battery from getting too cold to function.
Hood
Since puffer vests are often meant to be lighter, more minimal garments, many of them don’t have hoods, though some do. If the additional warmth is important to you, consider a vest with a hood. But if you’d like a vest that’s lighter and more packable, avoid the hood to save weight.
Price and value
Not all puffer vests are equal, and that’s especially true with price. Some are designed for fashion and some for function. If budget is your top priority, there are great options out there, but there are a handful of features you may have to sacrifice. Typically, when a vest costs more, it’s because better materials are used and/or the vest is made more sustainable than its less expensive counterparts.
How we tested
We tested these vests primarily in Colorado’s high country, in and around the mountains of Breckenridge. We took the vests hiking and camping, and we packed them in for multi-day backpacking adventures. We wore them for drizzly foraging hikes in the woods searching for wild berries and mushrooms, and even for hanging in town. We considered warmth, features, weatherproofing, and durability when testing these vests. Along with our testing out on the trail, we conducted side-by-side tests at home, comparing water resistance and warmth in a controlled environment.
FAQ
What do you wear under a down vest?
What you wear under a down vest will depend on the weather and the activity you’re doing. If you’re moving in the vest, on a hike or other outdoor activity, you’ll want a lighter layer like a base layer to avoid overheating. But if you’re hanging around the campfire, you may want a warmer layer, like a fleece, underneath. Down vests are great for insulating, but they’re not waterproof. If you’re out in wet weather, throw a rain jacket over your vest to keep you both warm and dry. You could also layer a vest under a ski jacket in winter to keep your core extra toasty when riding the chairlift.
Should a down vest be tight?
A down vest can be loose or more fitted, depending on how you want to be able to layer it. But one thing to consider with a down vest is that you don’t want it to fit so snug that the down is not able to fully loft. It’s best to opt for something slightly fitted without being tight.
What’s the difference between down and synthetic insulation?
Down insulation is very light and very warm, and it is highly compressible. This makes it ideal for insulating, especially when weight and space savings are important when packing the layer away. Down feathers offer superior loft, which creates dead air space in a garment, and that’s what makes it so warm.
However, there are some disadvantages to down. First, it’s typically more expensive than synthetic insulation. Second, unless it’s treated with a hydrophobic coating, down loses its loft when it gets wet, and therefore loses its warmth. Lastly, down can be more delicate and requires more specific care than most synthetic insulated garments.
Synthetic insulation does not have as good of a warmth-to-weight ratio as down since it is not as lofty, and it’s typically a little heavier and less packable than down. But, synthetic insulation does not lose its loft when wet so it maintains some of its warmth. Lastly,, and synthetic insulation is typically more affordable than down and easier to care for.
Are insulated vests suitable for extreme cold?
Insulated vests can be very helpful as a layering piece for extreme cold, but they are not warm enough on their own. If you are in extreme cold, you will want a full winter coat—a lofty parka is best.
Can insulated vests be packed easily?
Insulated vests, especially down ones, are often very packable and compressible and many of them are even able to stuff into their own pocket for packing. Some vests are lighter and more packable than others, so consider those features when selecting a vest.
What temperature should you wear a puffer vest?
Puffer vests can be great for a variety of temperatures, from a cool summer night or a chilly fall day to a mid-winter snow day, if layered appropriately.
Why do bankers wear vests?
The primary reason why bankers wear puffer vests, according to Marketplace, is because they offer a more casual and comfortable look that still maintains a certain level of professionality. Working in a bank does not require the technical apparel features that most of these vests offer, but perhaps it helps them dream of far-off places while working under the fluorescent lights.
About the author / why you should trust us
A true mountain dweller, Stasia feels far more at home on a high alpine ridge than on a busy city street. She’s worked as a backpacking guide in Southeast Alaska, has held a WFR certification, AIARE 1, AIARE 2, and Avalanche Rescue certifications, and is working to become an avalanche education instructor. She’s now a full-time freelance writer and editor working primarily in outdoor recreation. Her bylines can be found in Backpacker, 5280, and REI’s Uncommon Path, among others, and she’s been testing and writing about gear for nearly a decade. She is also the managing editor of the new print backpacking zine, Trails Magazine.
Stasia has been testing outdoor apparel and gear for nearly a decade for publications like Backpacker, REI, and more. Along with her editorial expertise, she spends almost every day getting outside, whether hiking, backpacking, mountain biking, or backcountry skiing. When working as a backcountry guide in Alaska, she was particularly hard on gear and is now always highly critical of outdoor gear and apparel, including what makes a good vest. Both because of her outdoor experience and outdoor industry journalism experience, she’s able to dive deep into materials, quality, and performance when testing.
Stasia is a lifelong backpacker, skier, hiker, mountain biker, and trail runner passionate about lowering barriers to entry for outdoor sports. When she’s not writing or cooking, you’ll find her in the mountains, probably above treeline, and probably testing gear.
